Post
by ranger » July 19th, 2010, 2:41 am
BTW, I think that Mike VB is right that the erg is not the best thing to do to improve your OTW rowing, if you do things like 2:00 @ 20 spm (10 SPI) for hours and hours, day after day, especially if you row at high drag.
The rhythm is wrong, and just in the way that Mike points out:
Rowing like that on the erg, you can't let the wheel spin; you can't let your dry boat run.
You slow down the drive, rush the recovery, rush the catch, cut the slide, etc.
On the other hand, if you row at low drag (e.g., 120 df.) and ramp up the power to 13.3 SPI (e.g., 1:48 @ 21 spm), the equivalent of that 9.4 SPI that Mike rowed this last weekend, there is no problem.
The rhythm of the stroke on the erg is pretty darn close to the rhythm of a good stroke (e.g., 9.4 SPI) OTW.
The drive is quick, the recovery slow, the catch well prepared, the slide full, etc.
If you are lightweight and are pulling 13.3 SPI on the erg, you are rowing well!
You are doing technical work that is directly relevant to your OTW rowing.
Of course, there are still a lot things that you can't do OTErg that you need to practice OTW.
But if you are a lighweight and you are pulling 13.3 SPI on the erg, the claim that rowing OTErg is _counterproductive_, vis-a-vis your OTW rowing, I think, no longer holds.
The question is:
If you are a lightweight, can you row a lot (e.g., 20K a day) OTErg at 13.3 SPI?
It is no accident, I think, that 13.3 SPI is right around the Wolverine Plan level 4 paces for a 6:16 2K.
1:58 @ 16 spm
1:56 @ 17 spm
1:54 @ 18 spm
1:52 @ 19 spm
1:50 @ 20 spm
1:48 @ 21 spm
1:46 @ 22 spm
1:44 @ 23 spm
1:42 @ 24 spm
1:40 @ 25 spm
1:38 @ 26 spm
This is the kind of rowing I did for several years in my RWBs routines.
My major mistakes, though, were rowing at high drag, with a cut slide, and given tense shoulders, too much back and arms too early.
I have now returned to this sort of rowing, but with these mistakes corrected (or at least, on my mind).
I am also rowing 12K OTW every day, after erging.
The two great challenges of rowing are (1) to row well at low rates and (2) to raise the rate to the max, given the distance, while/still rowing well.
Mike VB can now do one of these (row well).
I can do the other (raise the rate).
My goal is to work on technique until I can do both--together.
Is that Mike VB's goal, too?
ranger
Last edited by
ranger on July 19th, 2010, 3:01 am, edited 1 time in total.
Rich Cureton M 72 5'11" 165 lbs. 2K pbs: 6:27.5 (hwt), 6:28 (lwt)